Antisemitism is never an easy topic, and right now it is particularly complicated for many due to Israel’s actions in Gaza. But there is mounting evidence that we simply must pay attention both for its own sake and because when hate takes hold in a society, it doesn’t stop at one target. The problem of increasing antisemitism has been brewing for years (long before October 7) but recent events are shattering norms of decency and civility that for fifty years made open, virulent antisemitism a no-go zone – until now. Antisemitism is dangerous. Dangerous for Jews, dangerous for others, and dangerous to our social fabric and our way of life. 

 

Normalization of Overt, Explicit Antisemitism

For anyone tracking antisemitism, recent weeks have been shocking. There is perhaps no better place to start than Tucker Carlson, former Fox News host, and host of the number one podcast last year on Apple Podcasts. Carlson recently hosted Nick Fuentes, an explicit antisemite who has praised Hitler and uses the n-word to describe the people of Chicago. Carlson did not use his program to challenge Fuentes but rather gave his ideas sympathetic space, finding places of agreement and essentially helping publicize and promote Fuentes. Fuentes, for his part, used his time with Carlson to explain that the obstacle to unifying the USA  was “organized Jewry,” that Joseph Stalin was admirable, and other such concerning insights. All of this appeared not on some dark corner of the internet but rather was hosted by America’s most popular political podcast. 

Regrettably, this is not new for Carlson. Last year, in September, he hosted an amateur historian named Darryl Cooper who claims Churchill was a “psychopath” and “chief villain” of WWII while Hitler was misunderstood. The Holocaust, in Cooper’s telling, is some kind of unfortunate accident forced on Hitler because he had too many prisoners of war. Tucker praised Cooper as “the best and most honest popular historian in the United States.” Elon Musk called the interview “very interesting” and “worth watching” before later deleting his post. 

Image: Tucker Carlson. Photo credit: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0

Some conservatives like the head of the Heritage Foundation, have defended Carlson while others – including noted  conservative thinker Robert George and Republican politicians such as Ted Cruz and Lindsay Graham – have thankfully strongly condemned him. 

Tucker is not alone in spreading antisemitic ideas as the #8 podcast last year belongs to Candace Owens who was named Antisemite of the Year by the organization StopAntisemitism.

And finally, just this month, a group chat of Young Republicans was released where these young leaders in the party (most in their 20s and 30s), wrote things like “I love Hitler” and joked about slavery, rape and burning people in ovens. In addition, this new generation of Republican leadership prospects called African Americans monkeys and “the watermelon people.” 

While the examples above are from the right side of the political spectrum, antisemitism has also been apparent on the left in recent years. To take one example, this article about student groups at Columbia highlights many disturbing examples from celebrating the violence of October 7 to standing with a colleague who said in a hearing that “Zionists don’t deserve to live” and “Be grateful that I’m not just going out and murdering Zionists.”

While universities are often centres of such activism, it was perhaps more surprising and concerning to learn that one-third of Jewish-Canadian doctors are considering emigrating from Canada due to witnessing a surge in antisemitism in their work environments. 

That all of this is happening simultaneously indicates how normalized this discourse is becoming. Few of us would have imagined us being here a decade ago.

 

This Issue is Not Just Talk

It is well known that dehumanizing discourse helps facilitate violence. It is too soon to know the impact of this recent breaking of boundaries but we do know that antisemitic incidents and outright murder have surged over the past decade. In Canada, antisemitic hate crimes are up an astonishingly 400% from 2015-2024 (1,2). The USA during that period witnessed the largest and second largest mass murder of Jews in the country’s 250 year history. Just this past May, two young Israeli embassy staffers were killed in Washington D.C. 

Not Merely About Israel

Raising this issue right now is complicated for some due to opposition to Israel. There’s two things worth considering here. 

First, antisemitism is not some recent phenomenon and, as shown above, reported incidences started moving sharply upwards around 2016/17, long before October 7. The people affected are often Jews in Canada or the USA who have no influence or say in Israeli state policy.

Second, we should have these concerns regardless of what one makes of Israel’s government and its actions towards Palestinians. Whether you fully support Israel’s actions in Gaza, see them as genocide, or are anywhere in between, you can still find the antisemitism expressed above as immoral and deeply troubling.

Moreover, it’s not just about Jews….

 

Thin Edge of the Wedge 

Antisemitism often functions as the canary in the coalmine. Once you open the door to one prejudice and hate, every other prejudice and hate will rush to come in too. We see this in the examples above where both Fuentes and the Young Republicans made disgusting comments about African Americans. If you click on the links, you will also find comments joking about rape. Demonizing anyone’s humanity is a kind of virus that spreads. What starts targeting Jews will soon target Muslims, Blacks, women, and who knows beyond that. 

Photo credit: Canva.com

Jews and Muslim leaders in Toronto have long known this and before the events of October 7 caused such a rupture between these communities, they had established a practice of surrounding each other’s synagogues and mosques after terrorist events targeting their brethren. This began with Toronto Jews surrounding mosques on the Friday after the Quebec city mosque shooting and was reciprocated with Muslims surrounding synagogues after the Pittsburgh synagogue massacre. This was spurred by an empathy and desire to show allegiance. It also reflected a knowledge that we really are one and what comes for one will later come for us all.

 

Corrupting our Way of Life

Western societies have been undergoing a period of serious reflection and self-criticism over issues like sexism, racism, colonialism and more. There’s been valuable lessons from this. But it is worth remembering that these societies have produced some incredible positives too including enormous gains in human wellbeing and a tremendous spread of rights since 1960 that has few parallels in human history. 

But there’s no guarantee that will or must continue. Our liberal democracies rest partly on key values including: that all are equal; that we judge people by their deeds and character, not by immutable traits; that humans have inalienable rights worthy of protection; and valuing difference while also tolerating those differences we may find challenging.

Photo credit: Canva.com

Antisemitism and the bag of hatreds it pulls in its wake are antithetical to all of this. Further, as Yair Rosenberg notes, antisemitism corrupts people’s ability to think. It is partly a distorted theory of how the world works which attributes almost every problem to the hidden conniving Jew, operating behind the scenes. This uniform explanation for the world’s ills obscures the actual causes from our eyes, undermining our capacity to confront them and produce the changes we seek. It neutralizes effective political action and the improvement of a society, deluding us instead into chasing chimeras. 

 

Conclusion

Antisemitism is a cancer on our societies. Like all cancers, it spreads, it can metastasize into new places, sometimes taking different forms, and it threatens the well-being of its host. That host is us, our neighbourhoods, and our countries. We need more people like the conservative thinker Robert George (mentioned above), who will ignore political spectrums and instead call out this hatred wherever we see it. Together, as liberals and conservatives, as Americans and Canadians, perhaps we can find ourselves in five years in a better place. The bad news is how much worse things have gotten in the past decade. The good news is these trends remind us that change is constant, that current trends need not be stable but rather can be reversed. Let’s see if we can’t do our part to squelch this virus that threatens us all.

Subscribe To My Newsletter

BE NOTIFIED ABOUT FUTURE EVENTS AND GAIN ACCESS TO EXCLUSIVE INSIGHTS AND ARTICLES

    5 Comments

    1. Les gagnon November 6, 2025 at 9:37 pm - Reply

      I am sure this sounds like a STUPID question….but, Why do people hate the Jews? (I don’t buy, because they killed Christ!)
      I can’t get an intelligent answer…I often ask the question around the dinner table. I’m not Jewish I have worked for and with Jewish people all my life with no regrets….I can understand that the present war in Garza. Isn’t helping the Jewish image..I don’t like it either.
      Do we hate people just because?

      • Brian Carwana November 19, 2025 at 4:34 pm - Reply

        It’s a good question and has multiple answers.
        Partly, humans often marginalize minorities. Second, the accusation of being Christ-killers created a long, long tradition that pitted Jews as enemies of God.
        Third, in the 19th century, the emergence of Darwin’s ideas led people to see races as akin to species. This turned being Jewish from a religious category to one of blood or genetics. The Nazis adopted this.
        Lastly is conspiracy. Jews were forbidden from owning land in Europe and some turned to banking and being merchants. Christians couldn’t lend money so some Jewish bankers became wealthy which fed the idea of wealthy Jews controlling society.
        All of these things have combined together.

    2. Doug Couper November 7, 2025 at 8:47 pm - Reply

      A corollary question is why we allow the views of minorities (who supposedly hate Jews) to be blown out of proportion as if they represent the majority. I’ve lived in the GTHA for decades and don’t know anyone who hates Jews. I’d say the majority don’t hate Jews and those who criticize Israel are neither antisemitic nor anti-Israel. We can condemn the Israeli government and military for the Gaza genocide while asserting Zionism is but one factor in the continuing conflict. Foremost is the failure of the United Nations to deal effectively with Palestinian refugees when it created Israel in the world forum. Then there’s Iran, with its anti-Israelism, stirred by Shia apocalypticism, that is more anti-colonial than anti-Jewish.

    3. Helena November 17, 2025 at 10:46 pm - Reply

      Thank you, Brian, for being an ally and for this thoughtful post.

      @Les Gagnon – I suggest you read the book “Caste: The Origin of Our Discontent.” For a dominant group to maintain its power, identity, and sense of superiority, it requires a despised group. Anti-semitism channels existing prejudice, offers a false explanation for suffering, and binds the dominant group together through a shared enemy.

      • Brian Carwana November 19, 2025 at 4:36 pm - Reply

        thanks for the suggestion Helena

    Leave A Comment